I
have to say that this book would have been really helpful in sixth grade!
Apparently, this book pissed off the parents of Queens sixth-graders, who were
told to read this book that talked about masturbation over the summer. Bowing
to pressure from the outraged parents, the principal of Public School/Middle
School 114 in Rockaway Park announced Wednesday that "The Absolutely True
Diary of a Part -Time Indian" was no longer a reading requirement for the
summer.
According
to parents, all incoming sixth graders had been expected to write a
graded-essay on the book. Kelly-Ann McMullan-Preiss of Belle Harbor, who
refused to let her son read the book, said, "It's about....masturbation,
which is not appropriate for my child to learn at 11. It was like 'Fifty Shades
of Grey' for kids." Well, where are they supposed to learn about
masturbating then? Are the parents going to teach them? If I had this book when
I was in sixth grade, I would have been way better off. Considering my parents
never read the books that I had to read in school, they never would have known,
which brings me to another point. Why was she reading her son's book? There's
going to come a day when her son is going to want to learn about a little
self-loving and that's when she'll wish she let him read this book. People need
to lighten up!
Lines
in author Sherman Alexie's award-winning young adult novel include: "And
if God hadn't wanted us to masturbate, then God wouldn't have given us thumbs.
So, I thank God for my thumbs." Oooo! That is nasty! McMullan-Preiss said
she didn't want a school assignment to dictate when she had the awkward
conversation about masturbation with her son. I can understand that, but why
would she have to teach him about the birds and the bees? She has a long enough
name to be married. McMullan-Preiss planned to circulate a petition against
requiring kids to read the book before the school abruptly changed its
position.
The
book, which tells the story of a Native American who transfers into an
all-white high school, won the 2007 National Book Foundation award for Young People's
Literature. So, the book isn't really about masturbation and is clearly not a
"Fifty Shades of Grey" for kids. It just basically refers to
masturbation. Like I said earlier, "People need to lighten up!"
After
the book was pulled from an Oregon classroom in 2008, the author Sherman Alexie
defended the book by saying, "Everything in the book is what every kid in
that school is dealing with on a daily basis, whether it's masturbation or
racism or sexism or the complications of being human. To pretend that kids
aren't dealing with this on an hour-by-hour basis is a form of denial."
That is the truth and I say "Amen" to that! Queens and Oregon weren't
the only school districts to ban the book and to be honest; those are the
school districts where young adults should just be raised inside a bubble.
They're going to learn about all of this stuff in the book anyway. It's just
plain silly! Again, I'm not a parent of an 11-year-old, so I guess I shouldn't
really have an opinion on this. What is yours?
No comments:
Post a Comment